The Foothills Industrial Products Blog

Natural Gas Vs. Hydro Electricity

Posted by Melanie Takacs on Sep 14, 2017 1:45:24 PM

Energy- we as consumers need it to survive. The demand for energy in our modern world is ever-increasing. The pursuit now involves finding the most efficient, reliable, affordable and environmentally friendly options available. Renewables are growing in popularity for obvious reasons but they do come at a high price. On a related note, did you know that Canada is the second largest producer of hydroelectricity in the world? This substantial fact leads us to the question of increasing our hydro production even further. Currently, natural gas remains our nations highest utilized energy source, as seen in the chart below. This post aims to explore the various reasons to continue using natural gas to a higher degree, as opposed to increasing renewables such as hydropower.

 

                                       Canada's Current Energy Mix

Canada's current energy mix-2.png

Source: Energy Factbook 2016/2017

 

Recent News

According to the Globe and Mail (2016), Vancouver has already begun the controversial restrictions of natural gas in new buildings. This change has many concerned that it will cost consumers a hefty price. The question of the abundance of alternative fuels, such as biofuels, adds to the uncertainty.

A recent article from the Financial Post (2017), revealed that two-thirds of Canada’s electricity now comes from renewable energy. In 2015, Canada produced about 10% of the hydro capacity worldwide second only to China at 29% (see the chart below).

 

                          Top Hydro Producers in 2015

top hydro producers.png

Source: NEB, 2017

 *This image displays the top producers of hydro electricity. China is the top producer, followed by Canada and Brazil respectively.

 

Hydropower

Hydropower is created when flowing water creates energy that can be captured and turned into electricity. This energy source typically uses a dam on a river to store water in a reservoir. From here the water is released from the reservoir and is sent through a turbine, where the spinning activates a generator to produce electricity (RenewableEnergyWorld.com, 2017).

A pumped storage plant is another type of hydroelectric plant. With this option, power is sent from a power grid to electric generators, from here the generators spin the turbines backward allowing water to be pumped from a river or lower reservoir to an upper reservoir, where power is stored (RenewableEnergy.com, 2017).

Pros and cons to hydropower.jpg

 

Efficiency

Hydropower is the most efficient way to generate electricity. Modern hydro turbines can convert up to 90% of available energy into electricity (WVIC, 2017). Most fossil fuel plants are only about 50% efficient.

 

Cost

In the U.S., hydropower is produced at an average of 0.085 cents per kilowatt-hour (kWh). This is about 50% the cost of nuclear, 40% the cost of fossil fuel, and 25% the cost of using natural gas (WVIC, 2017).

costs of hydro.png

Source: IRENA- The International Renewable Energy Agency, 2012

* The following chart displays the various installation costs based on plant type and their associated levelized costs

 

Hydropower does have many positive attributes beneficial to our energy mix. A high-efficiency rate of 90% is very impressive, along with the low cost to produce. Higher costs do accumulate when factoring the price of installing electric lines to cities, as locations are often remote. Other major drawbacks include the impact on fish populations and local environment.

 

What You Need to Know About Natural Gas

Natural gas consists mainly of methane, a compound with one carbon atom and four hydrogen atoms; it also contains small amounts of other hydrocarbon and nonhydrocarbon gases. Versatility is a primary reason for the popularity of natural gas in recent years. It can be harnessed to serve in a variety of applications from heating, vehicle and industrial process fuels, and electric power generation.

Traditionally, natural gas is considered to be a fossil fuel found in deposits beneath the Earth’s surface, where those pockets have arisen from the decay of organic matter over millennia.

In recent years, natural gas has also become available from renewable sources as well as traditional ones. Renewable Natural Gas (RNG) is a locally produced, carbon neutral energy source. It can be created from the decay of organic waste produced from farms, landfills and waste water treatment facilities; this is called biogas (Fortis BC, 2017). From here, the biogas is captured and purified, until only methane remains, and finally injected into the natural gas distribution grid.

Pros and cons to nat gas.jpg

 

Efficiency

Unaccounted For Gas (UFG)- is the difference between the physical input of gas entering into a pipeline system and the physical output of gas exiting the pipeline system. The majority of unaccounted-for gas is measurement related.

According to AUC (2015), the three-year average of UFG was 1.220% from the years 2012-2014, see chart below. This leads to the conclusion that natural gas is about 98% efficient within Canada.

UFG.png

Source: (AUC) Alberta Utilities Commission, 2015

 

 Cost

According to the EIA, the average price of natural gas for electric power producers in the U.S. (2015) was $3.37 per thousand cubic feet.

 

Natural gas is a vital source of energy for consumers for many reasons including the fact that it’s a versatile fuel source, abundant, safe and the cleanest of the fossil fuels. Another distinguishing factor is cost; natural gas rates remain significantly lower than electricity (more than five times cheaper). Natural gas is not a perfect fuel by any means and does come with setbacks such as producing greenhouse gases and is also highly combustible.

 

As part of the modern world, we all require reliable energy to carry out the lifestyle we have become accustomed to living. This means the hunt for the best energy sources is still on, as each type comes with its own set of pros and cons associated with usage. A recent trend is renewables increasing in popularity, with two-thirds of Canada’s electricity now being provided from renewable energy. More specific to hydro, Canada is the second largest producer of hydroelectricity in the world. For the time being natural gas will remain the major powerhouse in Canada, some of the main reasons being affordability, reliability and clean attributes. Recent improvements have been introduced such as renewable natural gas and more efficient technology, which combined are working to keep gas competitive within the energy market. The future of energy is looking like a combination of renewables with natural gas used to support reliability and keep costs contained.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

Anything We Can Help You Answer?

 Ask Us!

 

 

Similar Blog Posts:

Natural Gas Vs. Solar Electricity

Where Would We Be Without...Petroleum Products?

 

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sources

AUC (Alberta Utilities Commission (2015). Atco Gas and Pipelines Ltd. 2015-2016 Ride D Application, page 6. http://www.auc.ab.ca/regulatory_documents/ProceedingDocuments/2015/20737-D01-2015.pdf

 

Energy Factbook (2016).https://www.nrcan.gc.ca/sites/www.nrcan.gc.ca/files/energy/files/pdf/EnergyFactBook2015-Eng_Web.pdf

 

Financial Post. Two thirds of Canada’s electricity now comes from renewable energy. http://business.financialpost.com/news/two-thirds-of-canadas-electricity-now-comes-from-renewable-energy#comments-area

 

Fortis BC (2017). Renewable Natural Gas. https://www.fortisbc.com/NaturalGas/RenewableNaturalGas/Pages/default.aspx

 

IRENA- The International Renewable Energy Agency (2012). Hydropower. https://www.irena.org/documentdownloads/publications/re_technologies_cost_analysis-hydropower.pdf

 

NEB (2017).Canada’s Adoption of Renewable Power Sources- Energy Market Analysis. https://www.neb-one.gc.ca/nrg/sttstc/lctrct/rprt/2017cnddptnrnwblpwr/hdr-eng.html

RenewableEnergyWorld.com (2017). Hydropower. http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/hydropower/tech.html

 

The Globe and Mail (2017). Vancouver begins controversial restrictions on natural gas. https://beta.theglobeandmail.com/news/british-columbia/vancouver-begins-controversial-restrictions-on-natural-gas/article34846098/?ref=http://www.theglobeandmail.com&

 

WVIC (2017). Facts About Hydropower. http://www.wvic.com/Content/Facts_About_Hydropower.cfm

 

Topics: Natural Gas Industry, Energy East, hydroelectricity, hydropower, hydro, canada, renewables, vancouver, hydroelectric plant, renewable natural gas

Connect With Us On Social Media

LinkedinYAFacebookYA TwitterYAGoogle+YA            

                                                    

Subscribe to Email Updates

Feb1.jpg

Download FIPs Latest Newsletter